Formal Definition Of Philosophy

![]() |
No items matching your keywords were found.
What do the Jews here think of this new ODD JUDAISM?
I just read about this on another post. I couldn't believe what I was reading. What do you think about it?
Humanistic Judaism:
WHAT WE BELIEVE – THE PHILOSOPHY OF HUMANISTIC JEWS
Humanistic Jews affirm that:
"A Jew is someone who identifies with the history, culture and future of the Jewish people."
This definition:
[it] INCLUDES ALL PEOPLE WHO WANT TO BE JEWISH
WITHOUT REQUIRING THAT THEY BE BORN
OF A JEWISH MOTHER OR FATHER - OR -
THAT THEY CONVERT TO JUDAISM
IN ANY FORMAL WAY.
So if you want to be a Jew, you're a Jew. Nothing else needed.
http://www.jewishtoronto.net/page.aspx?id=77578
All that is required is the individual’s decision to be Jewish. Humanistic Jews reject the idea of “conversion” in which a person becomes Jewish by taking on a particular set of beliefs because in reality Jews have no set of shared beliefs by which we can define who is a Jew.
http://www.humanisticjudaismla.org/id24.html
Look, I was surprised too when I read that!!
I'm a Christian (Protestant) and well, I have researched a lot about Judaism and there are not unified opinions on who is a "Jew" and who isn't. That Humanistic group you list above doesn't stress or emphasizes on religion. It's rather a philosophical tendency and it's not very new. And yes, you wrote it right: " So if you want to be a Jew, you're a Jew. Nothing else needed".
Many rabbinical councils won't agree with this statement or with what these non-religious groups believe. There are some GENETIC TESTS that have been going around lately that have proven most of the JEWS in the world to be genetically related or connected, with kind of like a Semitic common origin, because that's where they come from. So, technically a person could say he or she is a Jew, even if he/she practices or believes another confession. Nobody can rebuke him since there's no formal authority or regulating body that states officially who is a Jew and who isn't. Rabbinical authorities are the ONLY ORGANISMS that can say who is a JEW and who is not, but that only applies to religious families. To the denominated 'secular Jews', no regulation can apply.
Even the Ministry of Absorption of Israel, which is in charge of the Aliyas, or IMMIGRATION to Israel hasn't officialy taken a policy to say "You are a Jew, you aren't". Basically, anybody who has a Jewish ancestor and can prove it with a synagogue membership, or any certificate that officially states a person's religion as "Judaism" is enough. Theories have emerged everywhere quoting the "nonexistence" of the Jewish people, alleging that most of those who consider themselves Jews or practice the Jewish religion are descendants of converted tribes and peoples from distant corners of the world. There is another theory that says that the PASHTUNS people are descendants of the Jews during their exile in Babylon many centuries ago.
I'm confused too, but this is one of the topics with which you can't prove somebody wrong or right. Information is manipulated everywhere to benefit economic and political interests. Nowdays, it's "politically incorrect" to face the truth or at least question it regarding certain matters.
Hope you can find out more!!
Thank you!
Superstar Students: A Philosophy of Learning
![]() |
Meaning and Grammar - 2nd Edition: An Introduction to Semantics |
|
This self-contained introduction to natural language semantics addresses the major theoretical questions in the field. The authors introduce the systematic study of linguistic meaning through a sequence of formal tools and their linguistic applications... |
![]() |
Introduction to Logic |
|
Easy-to-read, visually appealing, and chock full of real-world applications, this most complete and authoritative book on introductory logic fully prepares users to understand, recognize, and apply classical syllogistic logic and the more powerful techniques of modern symbolic logicexplaining all concepts and techniques clearly, accurately, and thoroughly, and bringing them to life using a wealth of real-life examples of lively arguments and explanations drawn from a wide variety of sources to help demonstrate the application of logical principles by serious writers and thinkers trying to solve real problems in a wide range of fields... |
![]() |
What is Meaning?: Fundamentals of Formal Semantics (Fundamentals of Linguistics) |
|
What is Meaning? is a concise introduction to the field of semantics as it is actually practiced. The book explains the fundamental ideas and some of the most significant results of modern semantic theory in an intuitive, engaging manner without relying on formalization or getting bogged down in technical skills... |













US $14.95



